Who am I?

The peicurmudgeon, also known as John Underhay is just your average mentally ill, left wing atheist, SCUBA diving, snorkeling, biker.

How I travel

I like to think of myself as a sceptic, especially of the supernatural – as in anything that people try to explain by ignoring the laws and rules of physics, chemistry, biology, or by being otherwise contrary to our natural world. I post about science, pseudoscience, politics, religion, or anything else that intrigues, angers, or interests me.

If you landed here searching for the 1998 movie, I am not Jackie Chan.

I’m a 6th generation Prince Edward Islander, living on a disability pension and just getting crankier as I age.

Here is a Facebook Page for PEI Atheists who are looking to meet and hang out over beverages.

41 Responses to Who am I?

  1. Mike Larter says:

    Just wanted to say that it is great to see another Atheist here on PEI, living in Summerside right now and the number of the faithful here is staggering. Keep up the good work!

    • Thanks for reading. Summerside can be a bit on the religious end of things alright.

    • West says:

      Hi Mike I am an athiest living in Summerside.Wouldn’t mind chatting with you sometime.

      • west says:

        Hi John, I just wanted to share my experience with you about what happened to me. While I was working at linkletter park in Summerside 2001 on a shift from 12pm to 8am working security I had to deal with bad prayers taped to the doors, religious books left out in the open. I took down prayers everynight. This was posted there by the forewoman and co-worker. There was also a larhe sign God Bless You on the laundry room door. Went to see my M>L>A> who I found out has prayer meetings at her home twice a week. I ended up quitting my job and got drunk after 20 years of being sober.Went back on August 4th 2012 to another prayer on the door. Here it is

        Heavenly father, look down on us your humble servants

        who are doomed to travel this earth, taking photograghs mailing

        postcards, buying souveneirs and walking around in drip dry underwear.

        Give us this day divine guidance in the selection of our hotels that we

        may find our reservations honoured, our rooms made up and hot water

        running from the faucets. We pray that the telephones work and the

        operators speak our tongue. Lead us dear Lord to good inexpensive restaurants

        where the food is supberb, the waiters friendly and the wine included in the

        price. Give us the wisdom to tip correctly in currencies we do not understand.

        Forgive us for undertipping out of ignorance and overtipping out of fear.

        Make the natives love us for what we are and not for what we contribute to their

        wordly goods. Grant us the strength to visit museums, and castles listed as musts

        in the guide books.And if per chance we skip a historic monument to take a nap after lunch

        have mercy on us, for our flesh is weak.

        FOR HUSBAND ONLY- Dear God keep our wives from shopping sprees and protect them from”bargains”

        they do not need or can’t afford. Lead them into temptatation for they know not what they do.

        FOR WIVES ONLY Almighty father keep our husbands from looking at foreign woman and comparing them to us.

        Save them from making fools of themselves at nightclubs and cafes. Above all DO nOT forgive them their trespasses

        for they know not what they do.
        Put a claim into human rights on August 9th, and they sent a letter to the forewoman and the co-worker and to the provincial park manager.
        Like to hear your thoughts on this. Thanks

  2. Food for Thought says:

    Hi Curmudgeon,

    Do you know that the term “athiest” is self-refuting? If there is no God, then why use a word meaning he doesn’t exist? It makes no sense. A more honest word would be to call yourself an agnostic because, let’s face it, even you don’t know for sure and in you last breath on earth, you will be wondering if you might have been wrong. Some food for thought. An athiest is really just someone rebelling against God, who hasn’t really looked at all the possibilities.

    You may want to read “The New Athiesm and the Erosion of Freedom” by Dr. Robert Morey which explains all of this and uses very logical thinking on the existence of God, etc. and how, without God or a higher standard to live by, there are no absolutes, i.e. no right and wrong. It goes very deep if you think about it. Who built the hospitals, schools, churches? It wasn’t the athiests. What have they added to the world? Oh ya, there was Hitler, but without right and wrong, he would be okay. Do you think Hitler was good? If so, then God help you. How do you explain creation, our planet, the stars, their alignment, the sun? You can’t claim evolution, because it’s already been debased, though a lot of the non-thinkers cling to it because they have nothing else. Even Darwin denied it on his death bed. So, you really need to have a lot of faith to be an athiest, so much more than anything else. Good luck with that.

    • Gene C. says:

      How many times will you have to write the word atheist incorrectly before you realize that you are spelling it wrong?

    • JRock79 says:

      Ok, I’m going to give this a shot.
      1. Atheist means the disbelief in all claims of a deity that have been presented.
      2. Most Atheists are Agnostic which means that if there is supporting evidence for a God they would alter their view.
      3. What if you’re wrong and it’s one of the other jealous Gods.
      4. The reason you think we are rebelling is because you believe you have a personal relationship with your non-manifesting friend, it doesn’t apply to the rest of us.
      5. The moral lawgiver argument is less than impressive once you’ve realized that empathy is beneficial to human survival.
      7. Why not scientists who have more than doubled the life span of the entire human race? Most of them are atheists, there are more scientist named Steve who accept evolution as a fact than scientists who don’t. We’re going with Hitler? Really? Are we going to ignore the Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, the Salem witch trials, 9/11, or the Pope telling Africans that condoms cause AIDS, just to name a few.
      8. The “Darwin denying evolution” rumor was started decades after his death by a woman his family claimed was never there in the first place.
      9. The big bang is a sound theory for the origins of the universe, is it 100% fact as is evolution? No, but just supposing a God did it gets us nowhere near the truth.
      10. Faith is belief in something in the absence of evidence, it is not a virtue. Faith does not apply to skepticism.

      Thanks for your time, hope this helps.

      • I particularly like your comment that faith is not a virtue, especially when it exists in conflict in facts. I read a comment earlier today that belief that your car will get you to Mars is a sign of illness; belief your care will get you to Toronto is quite reasonable.

      • JRock79 says:

        You apparently haven’t seen my car, I’d be lucky to make it to Moncton. Great to see other free-thinking Islanders by the way, Happy George Carlin Day!

    • mark corrigan says:

      An atheist is someone rebelling against god without looking at all the possibilities? Lol, how ironic, you sir are a moron. People like you are a cancer to this world! If you are stupid enough to blindly believe in religion with your talking snake and 900 year old man building an arc then I truly believe you have no right to have children or to be allowed in public.

      Charlottetown militant athiest,
      Mark corrigan

  3. Food for Thought – I was going to write a rebuttal to your comment, but then realized that it would be a complete waste of time. You have just posted two paragraphs in which virtually every sentence contains at least one falsehood. Do some homework and come back.

    • Dan J says:

      The ignorance and lies of people like Food for Thought is simply astounding. Keep up the great work, John. PEI needs all the rational help it can get!

      • I’ve dealt with folks like that before, on the net and in RL. definitely agree with you.

        Thanks for the kind words

      • Thanks Dan, for leading me here.
        PEI needs more people who can think, rather than “Food for Thought”, who apparently starved their thinking processes long ago.
        Once FFT debunks the other thousands of gods in conflict with their specific belief system, including the variants of their own theology, I’ll be happy to hear them out. But until then, the site content is much more interesting than the rambling foolishness of a theist who doesn’t even bother checking their “facts”.

  4. ErikD says:

    John – have a proposition for you. Can you ping me at this email address?

  5. Trevor says:

    Nice blog! I’m an islander and fellow skeptical atheist but living in a land far far away. Out of curiosity I googled PEI atheist groups and came across your blog.

    • Is there any sort of group presence around here? ‘Skeptics in the Pub’ or the like? Could use something like that around here, certainly.

      • I don’t know of any skeptical/atheist groups, but I’d be happy to meet for a coffee or beer some day.

      • redskyonmars says:

        We have a SITP in Halifax now. It was started about a year ago. The guy who started it also started a CFI group here, but I think the whole SITP thing need not be associated with any particular group, if you were to start one up. Or if you’re ever in Halifax, look us up 🙂

        Centre for Inquiry Halifax

        Halifax, NS
        360 Inquirers

        Welcome to the CFI Halifax Meetup group.  The Centre for Inquiry is an educational charity which advances reason, science, secularism and freedom of inquiry.We do this throug…

        Check out this Meetup Group →

  6. Gail Rhyno says:

    Was just searching for folks who were blogging about Kandace…interesting read, your blog. Keep it up. Will be back 😉

  7. Matthew Oller says:

    Homer: “But, Marge, what if we’re going to the wrong church, and each week god is getting madder and madder?”

  8. Nance says:

    Of course even a skeptic can understand that The Laws of Physics have revealed there must be a Creator Who exists outside Time and Space, Who created The Laws of Physics, to begin with:) As to how a Creator can exist outside Time and Space, that is a great mystery and beyond our human comprehension.

    • No, the Laws of Physics have demonstrated that there is absolutely no need to use the supernatural to explain anything about the beginning of the universe. I recommend Stephen Hawking’s book “The Grand Design” if you are looking for an explanation. It is only those who do not understand physics who believe in the need of a creator.

  9. lissa16b says:

    Hey there, just stumbled upon your blog. Nice to see another fellow Islander blogging! I am faithful, actually considered Catholic, but I really don’t have any use for Religeon, and kind of think the whole Bible thing is a sham. I actually like to chat with atheists and hear their views. I am open minded and respect their views and mine, but it always seems that atheist are great conversationalists, whereas the bible thumpers are a little scary to talk to. They get all huffy and angry. Anyways, I’ll keep reading!

  10. West says:

    I just wanted you to know that I enjoyed your stuff. I am an athiest living in Summerside myself and it is sure a lonely existence. Sure would love to chat sometime. Thanks

  11. arkenaten says:

    Bumped into you over at Rebecca Hamilton’s blog. Sorry, can’t suggest you pop over to my blog as I took it down last week. But It might be subject to Ressurection (sic ;)) at some stage.
    I am thoroughly enjoying reading your posts.
    The one you wrote about oral removal of a child’s foreskin for religious purposes freaked me out. Great post, nonetheless. And the post on ivory was excellent.

  12. west says:

    hi john in regards to the prayer and humanrights their answer tourist prayer is a humorous representation of a belief system that no reasonable person would find offensive west

  13. John MacDonald says:

    Religious talk. Hmm.

    Starting with what I know, humans are capable of morality. Morality is beneficial to me and you.

    Now, I consider what is reasonable. it gets complicated because it’s reasonable that my knowledge (or anyone’s) is naturally limited. It’s reasonable to think religion grew/grows from our social instincts to belong to one another, to share in morality. Yes, power corrupts whether religious or political or economic or aesthetic.

    Miracles. Maybe miracles occur. Miracles may be beyond contemporary science. It’s reasonable we know comparatively little even within the reasonable possibility of a finite universe. It’s reasonable that human brains may be limited — some obviously more than others.

    I don’t understand xenophobia. I hope humanity is capable of compassion great enough to save ourselves. Getting along, not fearing others who believe differently or in a more limited way would be useful.

    I’m a PEI resident “from away.”

  14. luthier63 says:

    I recently moved here with my family and we are noticing a particularly strong aroma of religious fundamentalism. I fear for the future of my daughter’s education. Love the people here. They should start looking a little more closely at the modern world though.

  15. luthier63 says:

    By the way, I just wanted to add that I am not at all afraid to state my atheism in public, and I am very interested in meeting with people who share the atheist/secular/freethinking frame of mind. I love my family here, and I enjoy spending time with them, but there is only so much we can talk about before I start getting red-in-the-face reactions from them about my “blasphemous” way of thinking. I also want my daughter (who is 9) to be able to have a place to be free from religious influence.

  16. I ran across your blog by accident. Good to know that there are so many atheists on the Island. The only ones I knew before I left 16 years ago were members of the Unitarian fellowship.
    Incidentally, are you the John Underhay I worked with at Atlantic Veterinary College?

    Alan Donald, aka aharmlessdrudge

  17. Hi Alan – There has only ever been one of me. Indeed, it was your influence that helped me on the road to scientific skepticism. It’s difficult to be much of a skeptic without some background in statistics and scientific reading comprehension. I have been an ‘out’ atheist since my teens, but it was only after my kids were grown and I left the workforce that I have become outspoken about it.

  18. VileTemp says:

    Ran across this blog because of a comment you left on a Science Based Medicine article. I will check out the blog sometime, but for now, do you mind if I quote your comment in a meme sometime?:
    “I have always been of the opinion that many parenting difficulties could be solved by a glass of wine just before bed applied orally to each parent.”
    (Comment left one Separating Fact from Fiction in Pediatric Medicine: Infant Teething bu Clay Jones http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/seperating-fact-from-fiction-in-pediatric-medicine-infant-teething/)
    I thought this was both true and could make a nice meme.

  19. Ian says:

    Hey Guys, Just found this blog as well. Good to see more Atheists on PEI. I am quite surprised I haven’t seen a PEI Atheist facebook group as of yet. . . . I might have to start one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s